An 18-year-old girl’s death during a Caribbean cruise has led to a high-profile criminal case involving her 16-year-old stepbrother, who is now being prosecuted as an adult and ordered to remain in custody ahead of trial.

Keep reading to learn more.

Anna Marie Kepner, a high school senior, cheerleader, and aspiring University of Georgia student from Titusville, Florida, boarded Carnival Cruise Line’s Horizon with several family members on November 2, 2025. The group included her father, Christopher Kepner, stepmother Shauntel Kepner, grandparents, siblings, and step-siblings. During the trip, Anna shared a cabin with her stepbrother, Timothy Hudson, an arrangement that later drew scrutiny online.

On November 7, a cabin steward discovered Anna’s body concealed beneath a bed. According to authorities, she had been wrapped in a blanket and hidden under life vests. The Miami-Dade Medical Examiner’s Office later ruled her death a homicide caused by mechanical asphyxiation and determined that she had also been sexually assaulted.

Her father later described her as a bright and beautiful young woman whose future had been stolen.

Following the ruling, the FBI launched an investigation that eventually focused on Timothy Hudson. Surveillance footage reportedly showed the teenager entering and leaving the cabin multiple times during the morning after Anna’s death, including shortly before her body was found.

In February 2026, Hudson was charged as a juvenile after DNA evidence allegedly linked him to the crime scene. The case remained sealed until U.S. District Judge Beth Bloom ordered that he be prosecuted as an adult. Hudson pleaded not guilty to charges of first-degree murder and aggravated sexual abuse. If convicted on both counts, he could face two life sentences.

Initially, U.S. Magistrate Judge Edwin G. Torres declined to order Hudson detained before trial, citing concerns about housing him far from family members in Hernando County. At the time, Hudson was living with an uncle while under supervised release.

Prosecutors, however, argued that he posed a danger to the community. Assistant U.S. Attorney Alejandra Lopez emphasized the severity of the allegations and questioned what safeguards existed to prevent another violent incident.

After reviewing additional evidence, Judge Torres reversed his earlier decision. In a June 10 ruling, he stated that the government’s evidence was exceptionally strong and expressed concern about what he described as signs of psychopathy and a lack of remorse.

According to the judge, the nature of the alleged offense raised fears that Hudson could become violent again despite the efforts of relatives and caretakers. He wrote that the alleged crime demonstrated a level of depravity that would be difficult for most judges to overlook.

Prosecutors had earlier characterized the killing as a deliberate and barbaric act.

Hudson has since been booked into the Citrus County jail for a mental health evaluation and is expected to be transferred to Miami before July 10. Because of his age, he will remain housed in a juvenile section while awaiting trial. Court documents state that he will be allowed family visits and monitored internet communication. Jury selection is expected to begin in September.

Additional testimony presented during earlier hearings revealed concerns that had allegedly existed before the tragedy.

Anna’s former boyfriend told investigators that she had been uneasy around Hudson and described him as “a little weird.” He claimed that during one FaceTime call, he witnessed Hudson attempt to climb on top of Anna while she was asleep. According to the ex-boyfriend, he shouted at Hudson, who then ran from the room.

FBI agent Andrew del Valle later testified that the former boyfriend had shared the same account with investigators. Del Valle also said Anna had reportedly expressed fear of Hudson because he owned numerous knives.

Family members have offered conflicting perspectives.

Anna’s grandmother, Barbara Kepner, said the two teenagers had once been extremely close and described Hudson as devastated when Anna’s body was discovered.

Meanwhile, Hudson’s step-grandmother, Sonya Ziske, argued that the circumstances aboard the cruise may have contributed to the tragedy. She questioned the decision to place three teenagers together in one room and suggested that inadequate supervision may have played a role.

Ziske insisted she was not claiming Hudson was innocent or guilty, but maintained that the accusations were inconsistent with the boy she knew. She also noted that, regardless of the outcome, his life had effectively been destroyed.

Anna’s father has publicly stated that he does not support Hudson and wants him to face the consequences if convicted.

The case remains pending, with Hudson continuing to maintain his innocence as preparations for trial move forward.

• Florida girl, 13, made plea before being shot in face by stepdad argument

• Anna Kepner’s dad issues 7-word warning to stepbrother after cheerleader’s cruise ship death